Fairy Tales About Being 'Natural': Why Fitness Influencers Hide Doping and Who Pays the PriceArticle · digest for October 19
Dramatic chiaroscuro gym photograph: a man's natural muscular build holding a barbell under backlighting.
Article3 sections≈ 4 min

Fairy Tales About Being 'Natural': Why Fitness Influencers Hide Doping and Who Pays the Price

Open any social media feed and you are hit by a wall of sculpted male physiques. A 40-year-old influencer weighing 95–100 kg with striated, bowling-ball shoulders, year-round abs, and paper-thin skin looks into the camera and chirps: 'Zero gear, guys! I just wake up at 5 a.m., eat buckwheat, drink plenty of water, and follow my signature program—on sale for 4,990 rubles. Just believe in yourself and grind!'

Meanwhile, an ordinary person who faithfully hits the gym three evenings a week after work looks in the mirror, sees a perfectly respectable yet human physique, and starts drowning in inadequacy: 'Why don't I have shoulders like that after two years? I must be lazy, or my genetics are terrible.'

Coach Alexandr Alexeevich on the Telegram channel Atletizm dlya vsekh tackles a crucial topic: the 'fake natty' phenomenon—athletes on performance-enhancing drugs or hormone replacement therapy pretending to be 100% natural—is poisoning recreational fitness and distorting beginners' mental health.

The FFMI Index: What Unbiased Physiology Says

When arguing over who is 'natural' and who is 'enhanced,' gut feelings are useless. Sports medicine has an objective mathematical tool: the Fat-Free Mass Index (FFMI). It is calculated as:

FFMI=Lean body mass (kg)(Height in meters)2\text{FFMI} = \frac{\text{Lean body mass (kg)}}{(\text{Height in meters})^2}

normalized to a standard height of 1.8 meters.

In a landmark study by Dr. Harrison Pope and Elena Kouri (Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine), which examined 157 athletes alongside a retrospective analysis of pre-steroid-era champions (before 1960—John Grimek, Steve Reeves, George Eiferman), researchers established a clear biological ceiling:

  • Natural genetic limit (FFMI): hovers around 25.0 (the average among elite natural champions of the pre-steroid era was 25.4).
  • Athletes using anabolic steroids: scores routinely climb past 28–32.

What does that mean in real numbers? Take an average man standing 180 cm tall at a lean, stage-ready 10–12% body fat. At the natural FFMI ceiling of ~25, his maximum scale weight lands around 78–82 kg.

If an influencer of the same height carries 95 kg of lean tissue and insists it is all cottage cheese and meditation, the statistical likelihood of exogenous hormones approaches 100%.

Why 'Muscle Memory' Makes 'Former' Users Unnatural

Many influencers hedge: 'I haven't touched anything in three years!' Physiologically, they still aren't natural. Anabolic steroid use triggers a massive surge of new cell nuclei (myonuclei) inside muscle fibers. Even long after stopping the drugs, those extra nuclei stay in the muscle for years—or for life. They create a powerful 'muscle memory' effect that lets an athlete hold unnatural size on ordinary training. Calling that natural training is straight-up misleading.

The Real Cost of the Lie: Torn Tendons and Bigorexia

Influencer dishonesty is driven by simple commerce: nobody buys a workout plan promising 2–3 kg of lean muscle over a year of patient work. Everyone wants a 90-day transformation. For everyday lifters, chasing enhanced idols carries heavy consequences:

  1. Torn ligaments and joint wear. Drugs multiply muscle protein synthesis, but tendons and cartilage have poor blood supply and adapt over years. When a natural lifter tries to copy an enhanced influencer's explosive weights, the muscle pulls harder than the tendon can handle—leading to torn pecs, patellar tendinitis, and wrecked shoulders.
  2. Muscle dysmorphia (bigorexia). Constant exposure to filtered, enhanced bodies breeds neurotic dissatisfaction in men. Someone in great shape starts seeing themselves as 'small and fat,' which all too often pushes them toward underground hormones with risks of infertility and early heart attacks.

We have already unpacked this genetic ceiling and the role of myostatin and discussed why quick-fix transformation challenges backfire: lasting results cannot be rushed.

What Real Natural Athletics Looks Like

Recreational strength training does not exist for likes on shirtless photos. Its real dividends are waking up energized, keeping mobile pain-free joints, a strong back, healthy natural testosterone, and a clear head after work.

Stop measuring yourself against commercial storefronts. Compare who you are today only with who you were a year ago. Progressive overload with solid form, 8+ hours of sleep, and balanced meals will build a capable, resilient body that serves you well into old age.

Want a deep diveVotes help us choose what to break down in detail. This material has 0 votes.
Sources · 2