"It's roughly the same kind of diagnosis as chronic pancreatitis, which in the vast majority of cases doesn't exist at all." That's how Vladimir Korshok, ENT doctor and chief physician at the Atmosfera clinic, stunned cardiologist Alexey Utin at the start of their interview on the Doctor Utin YouTube channel. Before the stream, Utin collected questions from his followers and was surprised: half the messages on Telegram boiled down to one thing — how to properly gargle and flush the tonsils.
The scenario is familiar. You shine a flashlight into your throat, see large, bumpy tonsils with white dots, and get stamped with 'chronic tonsillitis'. Soon you're practically living at the ENT's office: flushes, antiseptics, and a fear of drinking cold water. Let's calmly sort out what's really happening in your throat and what actual rules decide the fate of adult tonsils and children's adenoids.
Where the forever label came from and what tonsil stones really are
Under the hood, palatine tonsils are ordinary lymph nodes at the entrance to your throat. They act as the immune system's first checkpoint, meeting bacteria and viruses from your mouth. The suffix '-itis' in 'tonsillitis' only means inflammation. It says nothing about the cause.
Korshok recalls a story from his fourth year of medical school. Students were given an old Soviet textbook with recipes like 'cauterize the tonsils with kerosene'. Out of curiosity, he bought a French textbook and read that the idea of tonsils as a 'focus of chronic infection' was pushed hard in the 1960s, but no solid data ever backed it up. More than twenty years have passed since then, and English-language evidence-based medicine still has no single standardized diagnosis of 'chronic tonsillitis'. Instead, the label hides a mixed bag of conditions.
"Wait," you might ask, "what about the white lumps in my throat? Isn't that pus?"
In most cases, no. The surface of your tonsils has natural pockets called crypts. Shedding skin cells, tiny food crumbs, and normal mouth bacteria collect there and pack together into tonsil stones (caseous plugs or tonsilloliths). Large, bumpy tonsils and the stones themselves don't prove a dangerous disease.
Digging them out with a spoon or flooding your throat with antiseptics is a bad idea. According to Korshok, frequent antiseptic rinses often make things worse by drying out the lining and suppressing normal microbes. Instead of brushing you off with 'you're fine, stop imagining things', a good doctor will suggest calmly tracking your next sore throat without fuss or extra chemicals. If cold drinks trigger sharp pain, gradual training works best: start with small bites of ice cream or cool showers, strictly as you feel comfortable.
Why your throat hurts again and again if your tonsils aren't to blame
"Okay, tonsil stones are harmless. But if my throat really feels scratchy almost every month, what's going on?"
The biggest trap is the familiar myth about a 'weak throat': sit under an air conditioner, catch a draft, drink something cold, and you immediately get sick. Korshok offers a sharp contrast: try telling that to a British person walking around in shorts at minus two degrees who somehow never complains about their throat.
In reality, frequent throat pain usually points to very different causes:
- Ordinary viral colds and the 'daycare cycle'. Everyone on the planet gets sore throats. As soon as a first child starts daycare, or a second child is born close in age, the whole family catches viruses back-to-back and lumps normal colds into a 'chronic illness'.
- Viral tonsillitis. In infectious mononucleosis (Epstein-Barr virus), tonsils and neck lymph nodes can swell dramatically, but it's a virus, not a reason for surgery.
- Dryness and nighttime mouth breathing. Hidden allergies to household dust can block your nose at night. You sleep with your mouth open, your throat lining dries out and develops tiny cracks, and normal mouth bacteria irritate it, causing a morning scratch.
- Sensitive lining and daily habits. Some people's tissues simply react more strongly to normal flora. When flare-ups last for years, a doctor will also check the basics: sleep deprivation, a poor diet ('pasta and sausages'), deficiencies like low vitamin B12, untreated cavities and inflamed gums, and in rare cases, gently rule out specific infections such as gonococcal pharyngitis.
Korshok is honest about oral probiotics and trying to fix your throat microbiome through diet: it's a poorly studied, experimental area. At best, it's a minor add-on, not a primary treatment.
Flush, treat, or remove: real criteria and real risks
True bacterial strep throat is caused by GAS (group A beta-hemolytic streptococcus, Streptococcus pyogenes). You can't diagnose it by eye just from redness and white patches. You need a rapid strep test. Korshok explains it simply: see 'two lines', and it's strep throat that needs antibiotics. GAS hasn't developed resistance to penicillin-class drugs.
Before discussing surgery, it's crucial to rule out an asymptomatic GAS carrier at home. Check the whole family, including a nanny or visiting grandmother, and treat the carrier together. Often, that immediately breaks the cycle of reinfection.
There are only a few real reasons for a tonsillectomy (tonsil removal).
The first is a repeated peritonsillar abscess on the same side: a pocket of pus in the tissue behind the tonsil capsule. Alexey Utin recalls his own experience: he had his tonsils removed after a second abscess on one side. He had never lost weight so fast because pain literally locked his jaw shut. After recovering, he rapidly gained excess weight because he had lost muscle and started eating non-stop. Once the first abscess heals, it leaves a defect in the capsule, making a repeat episode likely.
The second reason is frequent, confirmed strep infections. The 2019 AAO-HNS clinical guidelines set the international standard known as the Paradise criteria.
| Observation period | Minimum confirmed episodes |
|---|---|
| Past 1 year | 7 or more episodes |
| Past 2 consecutive years | 5 or more episodes per year |
| Past 3 consecutive years | 3 or more episodes per year |
Vague memories like 'my throat seemed to hurt a lot' don't count. A doctor must document each episode and record at least one objective sign: fever above 38.3 °C, swollen tender neck lymph nodes larger than 2 cm, exudate on the tonsils, or a positive rapid strep test. If the threshold isn't met, the AAO-HNS strongly recommends watchful waiting, since the benefit of surgery is modest and short-lived (up to two years). Exceptions are made for multiple antibiotic allergies, PFAPA syndrome (periodic fever, aphthous stomatitis, pharyngitis, and adenitis), or a history of peritonsillar abscess. Still, Korshok jokes that these thresholds aren't locked in a vault in Paris — decisions are always made in an open conversation with the patient.
This guide explains the logic behind diagnosis, but it doesn't replace an in-person ENT exam and isn't a prescription for antibiotics or surgery. See a doctor urgently if you notice:
- one-sided throat pain or noticeable swelling on one side;
- trismus (pain or inability to open your mouth), a muffled 'hot potato' voice, or inability to swallow saliva or water;
- high fever with patches on the tonsils but no cough or runny nose — a clear reason to get a rapid strep test and discuss antibiotics.
"Wait — if I remove my tonsils, won't infections go straight to my lungs?"
No. Current data doesn't show a reliable increase in colds or lung infections after surgery. The real risk of tonsillectomy is different: unpredictable scarring, similar to keloid scars on the skin. Thick, uneven scars can disrupt how the soft palate works, sometimes even letting food and liquid enter the nose, and such scarring is almost impossible to fix.
Adenoids in kids: why 'grade two' isn't a verdict and why to film their sleep
Children's adenoids (the nasopharyngeal tonsil deep behind the nose) follow a similar story. Parents panic at the phrase 'grade two' — if there's a second grade, shouldn't it be zero? Yet in 4- to 5-year-olds, adenoids covering up to two-thirds of the nasopharynx are a normal part of growing up. Removal is rarely discussed before age two (in breastfed babies, this tissue doesn't physically block nasal breathing while feeding). Most questions pop up between ages two and six, and by school age, adenoids usually shrink on their own.
Why did surgeries become so common? The pendulum swung. In the USSR, kids were tied to a chair — 'a medieval torture chamber', Korshok recalls, still remembering the face of the surgeon who removed his adenoids around age five. By the 1990s, doctors feared over-operating. Today, a child walks in holding mom's hand, breathes through an anesthesia mask, and wakes up to ice cream — and the pendulum swung back toward unnecessary surgeries.
Surgical bias also plays a role. Korshok sums it up neatly: "When you ask a surgeon, 'Do I need surgery?', they're actually answering, 'Can I do this surgery for you?' And they say: sure I can, I've got an operating room and two golden hands!" In a classic American study from the late 1950s and 1960s, a first ENT recommended tonsillectomy for slightly over half the schoolchildren examined. The 'healthy' kids were sent to a second ENT, who again picked about half. A third doctor repeated the exact same pattern.
There are two real reasons to remove adenoids. First, when a child breathes through their mouth for months outside of colds, snores, and has sleep apnea episodes (pauses in breathing with oxygen drops) — and dust allergies or orthodontic bite issues have been ruled out. Second, persistent otitis media with effusion (fluid trapped behind the eardrum for months without acute pus, threatening hearing) paired with adenoid symptoms.
When parents complain in the clinic about 'terrible snoring', Korshok asks them to film two or three nights of their child's sleep on a phone. Often, the video shows quiet nasal breathing with a closed mouth — and that short clip is enough to calm the panic and save a child from needless surgery.


