"Doctors Only Treat Symptoms": Why This Is a Dangerous Myth and How Evidence-Based Medicine Finds the Real Causes of DiseaseLongread · digest for November 7
Conceptual still life on a graphite table featuring an optical magnifying glass, an open medical atlas, and a vial of etiotropic therapy in soft morning light.
Longread7 sections≈ 12 min

"Doctors Only Treat Symptoms": Why This Is a Dangerous Myth and How Evidence-Based Medicine Finds the Real Causes of Disease

Do you know which advertising pitch effortlessly opens people's wallets around the world? It sounds remarkably simple and hits right where it hurts most: "Conventional medicine only treats symptoms, while we will find and eliminate the root cause of the problem."

It sounds tempting. When your lower back aches for months or your blood pressure spikes, a trip to the clinic often leaves a bitter aftertaste: the doctor listened to your complaints, wrote a prescription, and advised you to lose weight. Resentment flares up in your mind: "They didn't even try to understand why this started—they just silenced the body's signal with pills."

At that moment, a charming naturopath steps onto the stage. Looking into your eyes with sympathy, they say: "Doctors work for pharma companies. It's not profitable for them to cure you. Why fix the cause when they can sell you blood pressure pills for years? But we will cleanse your lymph, flush out toxins, and restore your adrenals."

In a detailed clinical breakdown, urologic oncologist Alexander Burlakov exposes the underside of this rhetoric. The claim that conventional medicine is supposedly uninterested in the causes of disease is a manipulative hook used to sell pseudodiagnostics.

Let's calmly break this down step by step: how therapy actually works, why medicine divides care into three levels, and in which situations hunting for a "mythical root cause" instead of proven pills costs a patient their life.

Three Tiers of Therapy: How Evidence-Based Medicine Dissects Disease

In clinical pharmacology and internal medicine, care is strictly divided into three fundamental levels:

  1. Etiotropic therapy (from the Greek aitia — cause). Direct destruction or elimination of the proven root source of a disease. If a microbe invades, we destroy it with an antibiotic. If a vitamin is missing, we replenish the deficiency. If a blood clot blocks a vessel, we remove the clot.
  2. Pathogenetic therapy. Pathogenesis is the chain of biological reactions through which a disease develops in the body. Often the cause cannot be erased in a second (for example, genetic predisposition or arterial stiffness), or the initial spark has already gone out while the resulting fire is destroying tissues. Pathogenetic treatment breaks the links in this mechanism.
  3. Symptomatic therapy. Targeting distressing outward manifestations: pain, fever, nausea, breathlessness. It does not fix a broken joint, but it relieves agony and prevents pain shock or brain edema.

To bring this framework to life, imagine a fire in an apartment:

  • Etiotropic level: shut off the gas valve, unplug the shorted-out extension cord, or douse the smoldering curtain. This eliminates the source of ignition.
  • Pathogenetic level: activate the ceiling sprinkler system and close the fire doors so the flames don't spread to the building's floors. The initial spark has already flared, but the path to catastrophe is cut off.
  • Symptomatic level: throw open the stairwell windows to clear carbon monoxide and put an oxygen mask on the victim. Acrid smoke is stinging their eyes and blocking their breathing right now.

When rescuers give someone an oxygen mask, nobody shouts: "Charlatans! They're just masking the symptoms of suffocation instead of fixing the wiring!" Yet that is the exact accusation alternative medicine levels at doctors every single day.

Hunting the Bacterium: How Etiotropic Therapy Saved Millions of Stomachs

Even in the mid-20th century, gastric and duodenal ulcers were considered classic psychosomatic conditions. Textbooks wrote about nerves, stress, poor diet, and excess stomach acid.

Patients were kept on bland mucilaginous porridge diets, given liters of milk to drink, and prescribed sedatives and antacids. Later came receptor blockers and proton pump inhibitors: doctors learned to suppress acid, and ulcers healed with scars. Yet as soon as the course ended, the disease flared up again. The finale was often surgical: perforation of the organ wall, bleeding, and resection—removing most of the stomach.

Everything changed in the 1980s, when Australians Robin Warren and Barry Marshall discovered the bacterium Helicobacter pylori. Marshall went as far as a desperate self-experiment: he drank a culture of the bacterium, developed severe gastritis, and cured himself with antibiotics and bismuth salts—work that earned the researchers the Nobel Prize in 2005.

Once medicine found the cause, a revolution followed. Instead of lifelong diets, patients began receiving a short 10–14-day course of eradication therapy—a combination of two antibiotics and an acid blocker.

Here are the data from a Cochrane systematic review (Ford AC et al., Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD003840.pub5):

  • With traditional maintenance treatment using acid-suppressing drugs or placebo, the one-year recurrence rate for duodenal ulcers was 64%.
  • After a course of Helicobacter pylori eradication, the recurrence rate dropped to 13%.
  • For gastric ulcers, the rate of repeat ulcers fell from 35% to a modest 4%.

The relative risk of recurrence plummeted by 80%, and the absolute difference was 51 percentage points. A two-week course of pills wipes out the bacterium, and the disease is gone for good. That is pure etiotropic therapy.

There are dozens of such triumphs. Consider hepatitis C: not long ago it led to cirrhosis, and grueling interferon treatment succeeded in less than 50% of cases. Today, direct-acting antivirals (sofosbuvir, velpatasvir) completely clear the virus in 95–98% of patients within 8–12 weeks. Or vaccination against human papillomavirus (HPV): studies by Palmer et al. in JNCI proved that vaccinating adolescents reduces the risk of invasive cervical cancer by 87–100%. We eliminate the virus years before the first atypical cell appears.

So why, in cardiology and endocrinology, do pills have to be taken for years?

The Puzzle of Blood Pressure and Statins: Pathogenetic Vascular Protection

"If a cardiologist prescribes blood pressure pills or statins for life, it means they aren't treating the cause—they're hooking you on pharma!" goes the classic naturopathic line.

Let's use common sense. Picture someone over fifty: thirty years of sedentary office work, extra weight around the waist, stress, salty food, and genetics. Over decades, their aorta lost elastin and accumulated collagen, kidney arterioles sclerosed, and vascular resistance climbed. The blood pressure monitor reads 160 over 100 mmHg.

What is the "root cause" of this pressure? It is not a microbe you can poison in a week. It is a decades-long complex of structural remodeling in the vessel walls. You cannot instantaneously restore youthful elasticity to stiff arteries.

This is where pathogenetic therapy steps in. Cardiology has proven that high blood pressure itself acts as a powerful driver of organ damage.

When the pulse wave pounds against blood vessels day after day under excessive force:

  1. The arterial endothelium suffers micro-tears, where cholesterol rushes in and forms plaques.
  2. Small brain arterioles become infiltrated with plasma proteins (lipohyalinosis), thin out, and form Charcot–Bouchard microaneurysms that threaten hemorrhagic stroke.

An ACE inhibitor or ARB pill relaxes the vessel wall and relieves excessive strain on the capillaries of the brain and kidneys.

Look at the meta-analysis by the Blood Pressure Lowering Treatment Trialists' Collaboration (BPLTTC; Ettehad D et al., The Lancet, DOI: 10.1016/S0140-6736(15)01225-8):

  • Lowering systolic blood pressure by just 10 mmHg delivers:
    • a 27% drop in stroke risk;
    • a 28% reduction in heart failure risk;
    • a 20% decrease in major cardiovascular events;
    • a 13% reduction in all-cause mortality.

That morning pill protects brain vessels from rupturing every single day. Calling it "empty symptom masking" is wrong: it is lifesaving intervention at the level of disease mechanisms.

Statins work the exact same way. An international EAS consensus statement (Ference BA et al., European Heart Journal) confirmed that circulating low-density lipoproteins (LDL) are a proven root cause of atherosclerosis. Lowering LDL by 1 mmol/L cuts the five-year risk of cardiovascular events by 21–22%.

We covered in detail how pseudodiagnostics tries to discredit clinical facts in Disease Denial and the "Subtle Plane": Why Pseudomedicine Is Dangerous, which shows in numbers the cost of refusing proven therapy.

The DiRECT Trial: How Losing Visceral Fat Reverses Type 2 Diabetes

For a long time, type 2 diabetes was considered a relentlessly progressive disease with an inevitable transition to insulin injections. However, Professor Roy Taylor's research group proposed the Twin Cycle Hypothesis: pancreatic beta cells in diabetes haven't died—they have gone into hibernation due to ectopic fat.

Infographic diagram on a warm white background clearly illustrating the Twin Cycle Hypothesis of diabetes from visceral fat in the liver to the pancreas.

Look at how this chain works:

  1. When a calorie surplus overflows subcutaneous fat stores, excess energy spills into internal organs.
  2. The liver is hit first: triglycerides accumulate inside it, insulin sensitivity breaks down, and the liver releases glucose into the bloodstream even while fasting.
  3. The liver packages excess fat into very-low-density lipoproteins (VLDL) and dumps them into circulation.
  4. This fat settles in the pancreas: lipotoxicity develops, and the islets of Langerhans stop secreting first-phase insulin on time.

Taylor proved that if you remove visceral fat, the cells wake back up. In the British DiRECT clinical trial (Lean MEJ et al., The Lancet 2018; Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology 2024, DOI: 10.1016/S2213-8587(23)00385-6), patients with diabetes were placed on a low-calorie formula (825–853 kcal/day) for 3–5 months while stopping all glucose-lowering medications.

The results were staggering:

  • In the intervention group, by the end of the first year 46% of participants achieved full diabetes remission (HbA1c < 6.5% without medication).
  • Among those who lost 15 kg or more, remission occurred in 86% of patients.
  • MRI scans confirmed that fat cleared from the liver and pancreas, restoring insulin synthesis.
  • After 5 years, 13% of the original cohort maintained lasting remission, and the number of vascular events was cut in half (54 vs. 117 cases).

Medicine found a tangible cause of the disease—visceral fat—and proved the path to eliminating it.

Anatomy of Pseudo-Causes: What Gets Sold as the "Root of All Evil"

When alternative practitioners offer to uncover the "hidden root," what they usually sell instead are fabricated concepts.

1. The "Adrenal Fatigue" Myth

You are told that stress and coffee have exhausted your adrenal cortex, causing weakness and sugar cravings. Next, they offer an expensive salivary cortisol test and a handful of supplements containing animal organ extracts.

A systematic review (Cadegiani FA, Kater CE, BMC Endocrine Disorders, DOI: 10.1186/s12902-016-0128-4) examined 58 studies: no link between feelings of fatigue and cortisol levels was found. The diagnosis "adrenal fatigue" does not exist. True adrenal insufficiency (Addison's disease) is a severe autoimmune disorder with plummeting blood pressure and hyperpigmentation, not afternoon office drowsiness.

2. IgG4 Food Intolerance Blood Testing

Patients are offered IgG4 testing against hundreds of foods, after which buckwheat, apples, and eggs are banned due to "inflammation."

A report from the European Academy of Allergy and Clinical Immunology (EAACI, Stapel SO et al., Allergy, DOI: 10.1111/j.1398-9995.2008.01705.x) states clearly: IgG4 is a marker of natural immune tolerance! Your gut regularly encounters a protein, and regulatory cells produce antibodies that protect against allergy. High IgG4 simply means you eat that food regularly.

The Commercial Trap of IgG4 Tests

Food-specific IgG4 testing is recognized as uninformative by leading allergy associations (EAACI, AAAAI). A positive titer reflects normal digestion, not disease. Eliminating foods based on such tests leads to protein deficiency and disordered eating.

3. The Myth of "Toxins" ("Slag") and Detoxing

In Russian alternative medicine, the term "shlaki" (slag) was borrowed straight from metallurgy. There is no slag in the human body: detoxification is handled continuously by the liver (two phases of cytochrome P450 and conjugation) and the kidneys (glomerular filtration).

In Anatomy of a "Medical Detox": Why Your Liver Doesn't Need Supplements, we broke down in detail how juice cleanses and herbal concoctions lead to toxic liver injury.

When Relieving Symptoms Saves Lives: The Physiology of Pain and Fever

In alternative circles, it is fashionable to sigh condescendingly: "Why suppress symptoms with pills?"

Yet a severe symptom is not just an abstract warning light. It can destroy tissue on its own.

Acute pain during trauma or a heart attack detonates the sympathetic nervous system: a surge of adrenaline triggers arterial spasm, blood pressure spikes, and the risk of cardiogenic shock. If pain is not relieved, a focus of central sensitization forms in the dorsal horns of the spinal cord, locking pain into a chronic, untreatable state. Painkillers save lives and protect neurons.

A fever above 40°C in a child or a cardiac patient leads to brain edema and seizures. Paracetamol or ibuprofen do not kill the virus, but they shield vital organs from thermal injury. Meanwhile, antiemetics during chemotherapy allow a patient to endure aggressive treatment and keep their strength to beat the tumor. Symptomatic care is a deliberate act of clinical protection.

Patient Compass: Three Questions for Any Seller of "Miracle Cleanses"

To protect yourself from manipulation, ask any practitioner promising to "dig down to the secret root cause" three direct questions.

Three Check Questions for Any Healer

  • "What specific, measurable substrate do you consider the cause of my condition, and is this diagnosis included in the clinical guidelines of the Ministry of Health or relevant professional associations?"
  • "Are there randomized placebo-controlled trials proving that correcting this number reduces the risk of disability or death?"
  • "What are the confirmed risks of the proposed diet or supplements for the liver and kidneys, and what is the alternative in an evidence-based protocol?"

A charlatan will insist that mainstream science is behind the times and that studies are rigged. An evidence-based doctor will calmly open clinical guidelines and show you the facts.

Evidence-based medicine investigates root causes with maximum rigor: discovering bacteria, creating vaccines, and putting diabetes into remission. Take care of yourself and rely on verifiable scientific data.

Want a deep diveVotes help us choose what to break down in detail. This material has 0 votes.
Sources · 5