At first glance, weight-loss logic looks ironclad: cut out fast food and sweets, switch to boiled chicken breast and spinach, and the scale drops. And if you reach for a pastry in the evening, your plan is ruined and the day is wasted.
In real life, that rigid filter derails you more often than it helps. Your body responds to an energy deficit—burning more calories over time than you eat. Your mind, however, wears out fast under harsh bans, turning one unplanned dessert into an excuse to give up altogether.
Ten weeks on cookies: what Mark Haub tested
In 2010, Kansas State University human nutrition professor Mark Haub set out to test what actually drives weight loss. For ten weeks, he maintained a calorie deficit, as covered in a CNN report and an episode of "CMT — Scientific Approach". Instead of his usual ~2,600 kcal a day, he stuck to around 1,800.
Two-thirds of Haub's daily calories came from store-bought snacks: Twinkies, Oreo cookies, Doritos chips, and sugary cereal. Still, his menu wasn't pure candy. To cover protein and micronutrients, he drank a daily protein shake, took a multivitamin, and ate a serving of vegetables—a can of green beans or four stalks of celery.
After ten weeks, his numbers shifted noticeably. His weight dropped from roughly 91 kg to 79 kg—a loss of 27 pounds (about 12.2 kg)—bringing his BMI to a normal 24.9. Body fat fell from 33.4% to 24.9%, a 8.5-percentage-point drop (rounded up to nearly 10% in Boris Tsatsulin's video). Blood work improved too: "bad" LDL cholesterol fell 20%, "good" HDL rose 20%, and triglycerides dropped 39%.
The lab shift has a simple explanation: losing excess weight and visceral fat improved his lipid profile. Overall energy balance across weeks drove the fat loss, regardless of the label on individual foods.
Mark Haub's experiment lasted ten weeks in a single person, and he warned directly that this menu isn't built for long-term health. Sweets lack fiber, complete protein, and phytonutrients, making it hard to stay full and support your gut microbiome. If you have diabetes, lipid disorders, or disordered eating, discuss any diet changes with your doctor first.
How one cookie triggers a binge: food labels and flexible control
Even when you understand calorie math, sorting food into "saintly" and "sinful" can trip you up. As Pavel Badyrov notes in a "CMT — Scientific Approach" video, a single burger or a couple of cookies inside your daily calorie budget won't block fat loss.
The trap snaps inside your head once a food is declared the enemy. After eating one "forbidden" bite, you scold yourself for weak willpower and feel shame and stress. You want to quiet that anxiety fast, and food is the easiest comfort within reach. That's how a tiny slip turns into a "might as well ruin the whole week" binge: guilt damages your routine far more than the calories did.
Psychologists call this dichotomous—or black-and-white—thinking about food, where items fall strictly into extremes with no middle ground. In 2015, Alexandra Palascha and colleagues in the Journal of Health Psychology confirmed that black-and-white food beliefs link rigid dieting rules to later weight regain.
A better path was described back in 1999 by Joachim Westenhoefer and co-authors in the International Journal of Eating Disorders. They split dietary restraint into rigid and flexible control. Rigid control relies on total bans and an all-or-nothing mindset, which the authors found paired more often with higher BMI and binges. Flexible control works more gently: whole, filling foods like meat, fish, grains, vegetables, and fruit form the base of your diet, yet no food is treated as a sin. A modest portion of your favorite dessert fits calmly into your overall balance—an approach linked in the study to fewer binges and steadier weight maintenance.

